Pizzano's Pizza & Grinders, Reunion, FL - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (2024)

(863) 424-9000

https://davenport.bestorlandoflpizza.com/

Review score

3.8

out of 5

Good

819 reviews

Review score

3.5

out of 5

Good

42 reviews

5/5Andrea Méndez

•

I gave this place a try and ordered a pizza using DoorDash delivery. I didn’t had the chance to take a whole picture but I have to sayIT WAS DELICIOUS!!DOUGH: delicious flavor and is not too thick nor too thin.TOMATO SAUCE: it was perfectly balanced, it didn’t overpower the pizza.TOPPINGS: were fresh and nicely chopped in small pieces.PORTION: medium size pizza is perfect for 2 people, maybe 3.PRICE: Amazing. it’s a decent and fair price for a medium size pizza.DELIVERY ORDER: I really liked you can customize your pizza. They allow you to choose what toppings you want in one half of the pizza and the second half of the pizza. And I loved they have the crust flavor option.I really enjoyed it❤️I’m a pizza lover therefore I have high standards for a pizza, they did an amazing job!!I would order again and recommend it!

2/5Nick Huffman

•

I wanted to like this place, I really did! I just moved down the street and this is the closet to my house and where my guests will be staying often.The only reason they got a second star was that the people were friendly and the pizza came out quick, probably too quick as you’ll see in photos.There was zero crisp there was no structure even looked under cooked in some places.I even saw someone come in and bringing “Great Value” ingredients from Walmart during the night shift! So you know from that what kind of quality you’re getting from this place.I obviously will never recommend this place to any of my guests. Disappointed

2/5Eli ?Darkstar? Gerena

•

VERDICT: tried a sampling of everything, the unmentioned were ok at best. The following in the long are the details on those that should be mentioned for the good or bad. If you can go somewhere else do it.Tldr: get the wings, with there spiced breadsticks. Leave the pizza mozzarella and deserts alone.The long story--The good: Buffalo wings and seasoned breadsticks. Wings were a nicely sauced that I believe a wide range of heat lovers will love.The great: dip the bread in the Buffalo and its fantastic.not bad but ehh: teramisu had no espresso taste, arrived frosty - cheesecake was okay, frosty as well one person had sensitive teeth the frosty put em off, they declined to finish it.No thank you: canoles- came in a bought package, was still sealed only missing label from where they got it, a few declined to finish after one bite, nobody wanted a second canole.The worst: pizza - mozzarella worth more then the sauce and pita like thin circular bread it was placed on, mozzarella sticks obvious frozen almost grainy texture in the cheese, marinara- not watery but lacking herbs damn near tastless.The worst were obvious, the deserts were going to be ok till the frosty bits and bulk order sealed packaging, giving another go for grinders and pasta later to give a benefit of the doubt.Update: sauce still bland,chicken parm grinder: calzone size and shaped cake of sparcely uneven placed chicken a splash of sauce in the center and a overflowing cheese ocean the chicken and sauce float in.Manicotti and lasagna pasta: watery probably from frozen, and otherwise would be fine if not for the bland sauce.Meatball grinder: thick cheese, meatball was par for the restaurant.

1/5Amanda Mack

•

By far the worst Italian food I have ever consumed in my life. I bought my entire cheer program down to Florida to compete at Cheer Nationals and we searched on Google Italian food the person picked up the phone was very personable and asked where we were from and we stated nj we have some of the best Italian food in the US so we ordered $285 worth of food mostly chicken parm dinner and Italian subs when I tell you it was the worst meals we have ever ate this place chef needs to go for training in Jersey please DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PLACE WORST FOOD IN AMERICA

5/5Matthew Shepard

•

Ordered the family combo. One XL half cheese and pep. One XL supreme. Order of wings. Cost was VERY affordable for our family of 6 and we had plenty of pizza leftover to enjoy the next day for lunch.Pizza was delicious. I like thicker pizza and it was delicious! Our picky children loved it as well. The wings were cooked very well, we enjoyed the mild sauce! They gave us garlic bread to try and we didn’t even order it. It was delicious as well! This place has cemented itself into our choice of pizza over the others! Well done!